Grocery E-Commerce: How Grocers Backed Themselves Into a Corner
StrategyNews

Grocery E-Commerce: How Grocers Backed Themselves Into a Corner

Grocery e-commerce margins keep shrinking as Amazon and Walmart gain share and grocers lean harder on Instacart and DoorDash to stay digital.

By VTEXNov 22, 20265 min read
grocery e-commerceInstacartDoorDash mergerAmazon groceryfirst-party commerce

Amazon's checkout prompt is quietly rerouting grocery e-commerce spend

When a shopper checks out an order of batteries or dental floss on Amazon's marketplace, the site now asks if they'd like to add fresh groceries too: a small nudge reshaping grocery e-commerce. That prompt is working: fresh groceries and everyday essentials grew about three times faster than the rest of Amazon's store and made up roughly half of all units the company sold in Q3 2026 [2].

Amazon CEO Andy Jassy told investors the company has found something real in shipping perishables out of its same-day facilities [2]. Perishables and everyday essentials gross sales totaled close to $250 billion over the past year, and Prime members' monthly fresh grocery orders for same-day delivery have more than tripled year over year [2].

Customers who buy perishables with same-day delivery also purchase nearly seven times more everyday essential units than those who don't, deepening Amazon's hold on the whole basket [2].

That is a direct hit on traditional grocers, who have long relied on shoppers tossing toothpaste and sunscreen into their carts alongside food to pad margins. Every item Amazon captures at checkout is one fewer trip to a supermarket.

Walmart and Amazon are winning on delivery speed

Fulfillment speed, not assortment or price alone, is now the main lever separating winners from laggards in online grocery, and the data shows Walmart and Amazon pulling away fastest. Walmart is approaching a 40% share of total U.S. e-grocery sales, according to a Brick Meets Click report cited by Grocery Dive, as both companies keep shortening delivery windows [1,3].

Online grocery sales overall are growing at more than a 20% annual rate and now represent around one in every five dollars spent in the grocery industry [1]. That growth is concentrating with retailers that have the fulfillment infrastructure to deliver fast and reliably, not with regional supermarket chains.

If a shopper has a good digital experience with a retailer, they tend to spend more of their dollars there going forward, which makes the current gap self-reinforcing rather than temporary [1].

CompanyE-commerce positionData point
AmazonSame-day fresh groceries and essentialsAbout half of Q3 2026 units sold [2]
WalmartDelivery speed and store-fulfilled networkApproaching 40% of U.S. e-grocery sales [3]
InstacartMarketplace and storefront infrastructure for grocersPowers nearly 400 grocery e-commerce sites [1]

Grocers' marketplace dependency is eating their margins

Grocers have leaned heavily, and arguably too heavily, on Instacart to run their delivery and e-commerce operations, with nearly 400 grocery e-commerce sites built on its Storefront Pro tool, Instacart CEO Chris Rogers said at the Groceryshop conference [1].

That dependency now comes with a direct cost: grocers have been cutting prices on goods listed on Instacart's marketplace to match in-store pricing, a move meant to retain digital customers that instead erodes margins because retailers absorb the fees they pay Instacart themselves [1].

Instacart argues the trade-off pays off. Chris Rogers said retailers that adopt price parity see online sales grow 10 percentage points faster than those that mark up products on the marketplace [3]. But that calculation still routes the customer relationship, and the data that comes with it, through a third party rather than the grocer's own platform.

The proposed DoorDash-Instacart combination, a deal reported at roughly $17 billion, adds urgency to the question [3]. Instacart's chief commercial officer, Ryan Hamburger, said the combined company would lower the cost to serve delivery through greater scale and reinvest the savings into the industry [1].

Critics see it differently: the United Food and Commercial Workers union called the deal a threat to shoppers and workers given the data and market power it would concentrate [3].

Can Instacart and DoorDash's merger actually rescue grocers?

Not reliably, because both companies' core model still depends on sending workers into stores to shop orders as a proxy for the customer, an approach that works at low volumes but grows less efficient as online sales keep rising. It also struggles to keep pace with stock levels, producing substitutions and back-and-forth messaging shoppers dislike [1].

“Against those two dynamics, scale is now a prerequisite for success.”
Neil Saunders, GlobalData [3]

Industry analysts see real benefits from scale, but caution it isn't sufficient on its own. Neil Saunders, managing director at GlobalData, said the online grocery market is becoming more competitive and cost intensive [3].

Bobby Gibbs, a partner at Oliver Wyman, went further, noting that scaling toward network density alone hasn't closed the profitability gap between online and in-store commerce, and that mature e-commerce offerings increasingly depend on membership programs rather than scale alone [3]. Grocers betting that a merged DoorDash-Instacart will fix their online economics may be solving the wrong problem.

The case for owning the customer relationship

Grocers have made real progress building first-party online platforms in recent years, but that is only the first step, according to Matt Van Gilder, former director of e-commerce at SpartanNash and now head of omnichannel at consulting firm NexChapter [1].

As marketplace companies grow more powerful, grocers need reasons for shoppers to transact directly with them instead, where margins are better and retailers keep the shopper data that increasingly powers AI-driven shopping [1].

Van Gilder outlined concrete steps grocers should take to pull shoppers onto owned platforms:

His broader point is that digital can no longer be treated as a side business. It has to be folded into the core loyalty and retention strategy, not bolted on next to it [1].

  • Study the customer's shopping journey to find where friction actually occurs, not where it's assumed to occur [1].
  • Customize online storefronts for individual shoppers rather than running one generic experience [1].
  • Reward customers directly for shopping on the retailer's own platform [1].
  • Build retail media experiences that genuinely help shoppers, not just ones that maximize ad revenue [1].

What grocers should decide now

Current macroeconomic pressure, with unit sales declining and shoppers financially stretched, has pushed many grocers to treat e-commerce investment as optional for now [1]. That is the wrong read. The channel's share of the industry will keep compounding whether or not a given grocer is ready for it [1].

The decision in front of grocers isn't whether to compete with Amazon and Walmart's scale directly. Most lack the resources to do that. It's whether to keep ceding the digital customer relationship to third-party marketplaces or to start treating their own storefronts, loyalty data and retail media as the core of how they compete, starting now [1].

Sources

  1. [1]Grocery Dive, Pardon the Disruption: Grocers have backed themselves into a corner with e-commerce — grocerydive.com
  2. [2]Grocery Dive, Amazon records rapid growth in grocery delivery — grocerydive.com
  3. [3]Grocery Dive, DoorDash-Instacart combination shines a spotlight on e-commerce pricing — grocerydive.com